Monday, March 26, 2007

Bethnal Green and Bow: Starters' Orders, They're Off


Rupa Huq has visited to comment on this story, and correct my spelling (see response!), with news that she has collected her first nomination in Bethnal Green and Bow where the Labour Party branches will be nominating THREE (including one woman and one BME candidate) and the affiliates are doing who knows what, but very likely one nomination per branch, mostly decided by General Secretaries and Political Committees.





Rupa also generously links to a Bethnal Green UNISON activist name of John Gray who gives a blow by blow account of what he certainly sees as sectarian behaviour from Tower Hamlets Respect.







This is in respect of a supposed template resolution on Islamophobia which John sees as a splitters charter to immaturely rant about New Labour, destroy solidarity within the Labour movement, and as silver spoon Trots letting down the real working people of Tower Hamlets.

Rupa is being generous in that John is supporting another member of the UNISON panel Ayub Korom Ali. Though she tends to agree with his post. That includes the following summary:

I accept that the proposer and many of the supporters at the meeting did genuinely believe that this template motion, was in their view, a positive attempt to "Say No to Islamophobia". But, and it’s a big But, the people who originally wrote it intended it to be solely an attack on the Labour Party and its supporters, and to libel them as racists and war criminals.

This is the comment which I left and on which I welcome your comments:

Mmmm. Clearly it should be Lebanon not Libya. When Reagan nuked Tripoli we ran a gig called Rock Against Reagan with RR's head on Rambo's body with the huge machine gun ... anyway.

I do mostly agree with this. But:
(a) government rhetoric and action on immigration and asylum is often unhelpful and the policy of deliberate destitution and threatening to snatch kids are hugely unhelpful and are in effect a call to soft racists to keep backing the LP;
(b) while you are quite right that it is the individual terrorists and those who manipulate them who murder people it is absolutely ridiculous not to own up to or accept as a fact that Britain's foreign policy is part of the landscape and contributes in increasing drip drip drips to unbalancing these people and turning them to homicide and suicide.

Also, it might be said that John is probably trying to roll over rather than win over people who simply don't have the benefit of joined up thinking, a tradition of a broad church, and the discipline of electoral party politics.

These may be the things that could be debated if Thursday's meeting goes ahead in any form.

FACTOIDS: Steve Bell's IF... picks up the Rambo theme with "Cambo" today. Bethnal Green and Bow CLP and their co-conspiritors ruled out almost half of those on the membership list. Those who had allegedly been recruited by contenders as their "gangs" purely to pack the meetings.

[The remaining selectorate is almost exactly the same size as that in Man Wit and so far four units have nominated and six candidates are up and running.]

Sounds like Lib Dem tactics that. They allow people to walk up, join on the spot and take part! Even babes in arms until very recently. Or Family and Kinship in Bethnal Green alive-alive-o and red in tooth and claw.

5 comments:

John Gray said...

Yes, but, no, but… We need to always remember that 9/11 (and other terrorist atrocities) took place before the invasion of Afghanistan or Iraq. Ironically the forward planning for 9/11 apparently began at the same time as American (and RAF) pilots were risking their lives attacking Serb forces in Kosovo (to prevent another genocide of Muslims). But you are right that current foreign policy has an impact. Especially the way that policy is often portrayed. By some people who ought to know better.

Chris Paul said...

Hi John, welcome

You're not suggesting that before 9/11 there were no irritating, infuriating foreign adventures and imperial gaffes affecting the world view of some of the poorest and most hopeless populations in the world? Or that American imperialism and in some cases guilt have been a major problem for the world for some time now. Their turn! Clearly not as you accept the general point. Which is more than Mr Blair will admit to.

The Kosovo/a parallel is interesting of course. I can't say I ever properly understood it although I was in daily contact with people under the bombs etc and hosted various visiting artists from the zone afterward.

But Kosovo/a hardly makes up for hundreds of years of high-handed action and inaction. It is a very weak point to make when you're bombing the crap out of people in all sorts of territories that you once (if belatedly) help save some of their co-religionists. Though even that classification isn't quite as simple as that.

Look at the venues for bother. Insensitive and careless imperial carve ups every one. Even the North of Ireland where a leak to the Morning Post of a very poor working model became a rather indefensible line on the map ... still there 85 years on.

Better news on that today though.

The SWP have a completely different world view than the LP and TU left. They are never satisfied because that is the way they are. They don't really do swings and roundabouts. Or discipline.

They are attracted by rather childish analysis or simply expect to win on every line of everything.

They major on guessing and ascribing motivations for events and decisions which have several equally possible and probable alternative explanations. e.g. X did this because he is an oil-grubbing running dog **** rather than X made a mistake but was trying to do good.

And they are always like the person asked for directions who says: "Oh I wouldn't start from here if I were you."

We know that. Some are of course more reasonable than others. And some are very good grafters who would be more useful in our movement in my opinion if they accepted that having half their programme in time is better than none of it right now. That's the thing.

A few SWP/Respect people in Manchester do a huge amount of good work alongside Labour and others to provide practical help to those in need, to help batter down the BNP threat, and to be a kind of roving conscience/thorn for the left.

The way they have hollowed out the peace movement by OTT pronouncements however is a disaster that was waiting to happen. But even there some are learning. And their anti-fash work is getting more sophisticated too.

As you said a good lot of very well motivated comrades driven by some strange lines.

Still, as you can see your piece was thought provoking so thanks for that.

Best w
Chris P

Anonymous said...

Already six candidates with nominations? Never mind the SWP tell us about the selection! We never got to six. Do we know what size of shortlist they are aiming at?

Chris Paul said...

Sorry Withington Local, still waiting for answers to these practical questions. Network not so good in BG&B just yet.

Anonymous said...

Family and kinship? Isn't that the same as RACE? Isn't that a reactionary concept or what? Or is it just anything you want it to be?